Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
The recent Border-Gavaskar Trophy 2024-25 has sparked intense debate about the performance of Indian cricketers in particular Shubman Gill. Once hailed as the next big thing in Indian cricket, Gill’s recent outings have raised eyebrows, with critics questioning his place in the team. A former Indian cricketer has also spoken about his position, calling Gill “overrated” and criticizing the selection committee for overlooking other deserving talents.
Shubman Gill’s disappointing performance in Australia
During the Border-Gavaskar Trophy, Gill’s batting was unimpressive. He managed scores of 31, 28, 1, 20 and 13 in five innings, which is a stark contrast to the expectations set for a player of his calibre. While the focus has mostly been on veterans like Virat Kohli i Rohit SharmaGill’s inability to contribute significantly has not gone unnoticed. His average of under 30 in overseas conditions highlights a worrying trend for a player who was once seen as a potential match-winner.
READ also: ‘Telling players like Rohit or Kohli…’: Yograj Singh stresses for better team management
The caption supports a call for change
Krishnamachari SrikkanthComments on his YouTube channel have sparked discussions about favoritism within the selection committee. He noted that while Gill continues to get opportunities despite his lackluster performances, the players like him Suryakumar Yadav, Ruturaj Gaikwadi Sai Sudharsan they have been overlooked despite their impressive records in domestic cricket. Srikkanth emphasized that new talent should be promoted instead of sticking with players who fail to deliver consistently.
“I have always maintained that Shubman Gill is an overrated cricketer but no one listened to me. He is a very overrated cricketer. When Gill has such a long string… some people might wonder if even players like Suryakumar Yadav could have been given a longer rope in the Tests.” Srikkanth said.
The case of other talents
The argument for promoting other players is compelling. Gaikwad has performed exceptionally well in first-class cricket, while Sudharsan has made waves during the ‘A’ tours. Their consistent performances raise questions as to why they are not being considered for the national team when players like Gill continue to struggle.
Srikkanth’s claim that “Gill survives because he has ten chances and scores on the tenth chance” resonates with many fans who feel that merit should dictate selection rather than reputation or past favoritism.
How India navigating a transitional phase in cricket, accountability within the selection committee becomes paramount. The current crop of players must be judged on their performance, especially in difficult conditions like the ones they are in Australia. Selectors must recognize that while potential is important, consistent performance is crucial to success on the international stage.
Ricky PontingGill’s remarks also echo this sentiment. He noted that Gill needs to trust his instincts more and avoid overthinking his technique, which could be contributing to his struggles.
