Emilia Perez’s arguments: Why the Oscar -nominated film faces a backlash

[ad_1]

Why Emilia Perez is controversial the biggest criticism of the film nominated by Oscar 169

Zoe Saldaña as Rita Moro Castro in Emilia Pèrez. Page 114 – What Not Productions – Pathé Films

Emilia Pérez Leads the package of 2025 Oscari Hopes with a Whopping 13 nominationsBut the film has faced many different arguments.

Karla Sofía Gaskón In the middle of the musical drama as a powerful Mobs boss hiring a lawyer (Zoe Saldaña) To help her fake her death and has surgery that confirms sex. Gaskon the first open transgender woman came to score nominations for the best actress at the Golden Globes and Academy Awards.

Directed by the French Director Jacques Audiard. Emilia Pérez It was performed for the first time in May 2024 at the Cannes France Film Festival, where it was immediately received. Gaskón, saldaña, Selena Gomez and Adriana paz were honored with the best actress while Emilia Pérez The jury award was given. However, criticism once hit the film Netflix the following September.

The cast and crew are aware of the arguments, and the director has encouraged people to see the film before forming an opinion. “I would like to tell the people involved in this debate that the film has not even been released in Mexico. They haven’t seen him, ”Audiard told Cnn in Spanish In a January 15 interview when discussing the backlash. “So, please, if you want to criticize the film, criticize it after seeing it. Then we will discuss it. “

The Oscars Nominations Snubs Largest 2025


Related: Snubs largest Oscar nominations: Selena Gomez, Angelina Jolie and More

Page 114 – why not products – pathe films – France 2 Cinéma; Pablo Larraín/Netflix announced the Nominations of Oscars 2025, and not all the stars, filmmakers and filmmakers this year made the cut. Emilia Pérez leads the package with 13 Academy Awards goals, including the best photo, the best international feature film (…)

Below are the largest contention points among Emilia Pérez Judges:

Mexican representation

Emilia Pérez Set in Mexico and tackles sensitive topics such as drug trafficking, gang violence and missing people. Critics note that someone who has not lived in Mexico under such threats may not be the best person to tell such a story, and some had even accused the film of ongoing stereotypes.

“If there are things that Mexicans see disgraceful in Emilia, I apologize,” Audiard told CNN en Español.

It is not just the subject that has triggered backlash. Gas comes from SpainNot Mexico. Paz is the only actor born in Mexico among the leaders. The film is also set in Mexico – but Audiard filmed Emilia Pérez in France to a large extent.

“I came to scout locations. At that time, I got every intention to film this film, ”added Audiard. “All, as a whole, in natural settings. But in the end, I couldn’t. I even thought that when I couldn’t do it in natural locations, I could make it a Churubusco studios, ”he said. “However, there were more financial facilities in France. But this artistic director came to Mexico to do research. He found many elements. We even came here to Mexico (a) Exercises. “

Why Emilia Perez is controversial the biggest criticism of the film nominated by Oscar 167
Shanna Besson/Page 114 – What Not Prindictions – Pathé Films

Suspicious Spanish

Many Spanish viewers raised their eyebrows while watching Emilia Pérez. Audiard wrote the script and wrote the French singer Camille the songs, and both had to work with a translator as neither spoke Spanish. The songs and dialogue have been criticized as stilted and awkward, and many social media users have noted that the English subtitles are not exactly translations.

“Camille worked with a great translator, Karla Aviles, who is Mexican,” said the director The New York Times in November. “But throughout the shooting we had problems, for example, with Selena’s accent in Spanish. She’s Texan. Karla Sofía Gascón speaks Spanish Castilian. She is from Madrid. Given that I do not speak Spanish, I lost the mood of a Mexican accent against the Castile on me. We had all these problems with accents, but we repaired them in the editing. We did a lot of voiceover. “

Audiard expressed his appreciation of the language to Cnn en Espanol in January, explaining, “Although I don’t speak Spanish, I think his musicality is very beautiful and I wanted to make an opera in Spanish.”

Meanwhile, Gomez, who is not fluent in Spanish, has faced backlash for her performance in the film with critics claiming to say she does not know what she is saying. Eugenio Derbez called her accent “inconceivable,” adding, “I feel she doesn’t know what she’s saying. If she doesn’t know what she says, she can’t give her any mood. “

Gomez Respond directly through Tiktok In December 2024. “I understand where you are coming from,” said Gomez in Spanish. “I’m sorry. I did the best I could with the time I had. ”He later apologized for his comments.

Why Emilia Perez is controversial the biggest criticism of the film nominated by Oscar 168
Page 114 – What Not Productions – Pathé Films

Cross -representation

Clad called Emilia Pérez is “a step back for trans,” in one article. The missing film was evident from the nominations for the GLAAD Media Awards on Wednesday, January 22. The Honorees are praised for meaningful representation of the LGBTQ+community.

Many trans critics have quoted various issues with the film, from the unrealistic portrayal of surgery that confirms sex to the way Emilia’s transfer seems to be equivalent to morality.

Autostraddle The film slam as “unique CIS nonsense” to be filled with over -played ropes for trans people. “It’s not about an offense or something not allowed,” wrote the judge Drew Burnett Gregory. “It’s boring. I do not understand why a film that is so bonkers in other ways chooses to undermine its strengths with this shallow understanding of her title character. “

In the meantime, Pink news He noted the biggest crime was that he did not feel at all as an honest story about transfer. “It is not the point that transient representation has to be perfect, but it has to be serious, and Emilia Pérez does not feel seriously,” wrote the judge Amelia Hansford.

Selena Gomez


Related: Selena Gomez has a sweetest response to win the best actress in Cannes

Kristy Sparow/Getty Images Selena Gomez shared her sweet response to Learning Won the Best Actress Award at the Cannes Film Festival. “I’m so excited!” She said into his phone on Saturday, May 25. Gomez, 31, received a call from Zoe Saldaña, who informed her that Emilia Pérez’s women had all ruled the best (…)

Use if

Sound designer Cyril Holtz He said a respeecher artificial intelligence company was used to change the voice of a gaskbone. For a song that took place before surgery that confirms Emilia’s sex, the director wanted Emilia’s voice to sound different. They used AI to fuse the Gascón and Camille voice, who wrote the musical numbers.

“In the case of Karla Sofía, it was more complex because parts of the field that were difficult over during an interview about technology in Cannes.

[ad_2]

Source link