Physical Address
304 North Cardinal St.
Dorchester Center, MA 02124
Sometimes in this the wild life stumbles down a rabbit hole that ends up being more like a vast abyss. Such is the state of interest and appreciation for the world of carbon steel pans. One might think that this humble kitchen staple might be overlooked in favor of the heritage cast iron source, utilitarian non-stick, or hybrid hexagon trending technology pan. You would be wrong; Carbon steel is not yet run, nor runner-up.
There is an intense and angry fandom for this style of cookware that also shocked me, and I write about, like, influences of mineral water. From a busy subreddit to a secret world of home obsessives and professional chefs to in-demand carbon steel craftsmen who sell their wares for a raffle ticket, the dedication and appreciation for carbon steel runs deep. It’s a subculture of roaring American foodies that has gone largely uninvestigated by the wider press, and I can only hope to scratch the surface of doing it justice with this guide (after the surface is scratched, of course, I recommend reseasoning the pan with grape oil on high heat).
What is carbon steel? It is a kind of pan style (made of an iron-carbon alloy) that shares the difference, more or less, between the easy utility of stainless steel and the long-term rusticity of cast iron. With the right care and use, carbon steel pans move effortlessly between different cooking styles, allowing you to fry an egg. and fry a steak, all with the same pan. There is a slight learning curve to use these breads, for which YouTube and forums (like the Reddit hub above) are your friends. But they are also tanks – they can be used and worn, and they can be reseasoned again and again to get the most out of your cooking experience.
Also be sure to check out our guides at the The best espresso machines, The best coffee subscriptionsand Best Meal Kit Delivery Services.
Turn on with unlimited access to WIRED. Get the best-in-class report that is too important to simply ignore $2.50 $1 per month for 1 year. Includes unlimited digital access and exclusive subscriber-only content. Subscribe today.
What type of carbon steel pan should you buy?
Carbon steel panmakers run the gamut in size and style, from tiny artisan operations to heritage brands that have gone big time to crafty Instagrammy upstarts (it’s like looking into a bread-shaped mirror of the America). The price of course plays a big role in the selection, and as I have tried and baked with bread over the course of a few months, I was surprised and impressed by how well some of the breads at the lower end of the cooked cost spectrum.
Take it from me, and the carbon steel nerds online, when I say that your first carbon steel pan will not be your last carbon steel loaf. Because this cookware varies greatly in size, depth and the best purpose, it is difficult to stop at just one. A flat pan works well for some styles of cooking; for other styles, a large, deep pan or even a wok is what you’re really looking for. My advice would be to start with one of the entry-level pans in this guide, then—when you’re completely #CarbonPilled—consider investing in a low-production pan from an independent manufacturer. Treated well and well-loved, a carbon steel skillet can become a family heirloom, the kind of thing you pass down to your children and display proudly in your home.
I baked and baked and baked with these breads over the course of three months, putting different models and styles through their paces and coming out with the above tips. Each pan in the guide was given a couple of basic cooks – a fried egg, a sauteed onion – and then, as I got to know the pans better, I started to think about them in terms of certain dishes and applications , poaching chicken in bread. Smithey Forge pan, for example, or using Lodge as my go-to for frying bacon.
Different pans were tested for each product category, with a focus on pans under $55, as well as “deep” pans and flat pans.
